YAY! It’s time for MAIL BAG! [Where Amy finally gets off her tail and does the best she can to answer your questions about LOST!]

THIS EDITION OF MAIL BAG focuses on lingering questions after “The End.” The finale left a lot of LOST fans scratching their heads (and/or CRYING their eyes out like ME). The good news is with the finale over, all the puzzle pieces are FINALLY in the box. The better news is: if you are one of those fans determined to figure out what happened, you are in luck! Team Rewatch here at LOSTblog is all about going BAAAAACK to the beginning and re-examining the entire show in context. Be sure to check out all our recaps, podcasts and LIVE chats each week!
This is a special edition of MAIL BAG is dedicated to answering excellent QUESTIONS from groovy LOST fan, Diane. Her questions and my answers cover similar questions many of my lovely LOST readers have been posting over the past three weeks. I’ll encourage all of you to read through them!
Diane wrote:
It’s me again, Amy. I’ve re-read your recaps and some of the other articles you’ve written about your theories, and they are very interesting.
Thank you very much! I’m glad you are enjoying them!
Did you come up with this on your own?
I didn’t start really digging into LOST until after the Season 3 finale (first flash forward), and even then, I spent very little time debating/discussion the show with other peeps on a regular basis. I’m not the only fan (by FAR) who made a strong case that nothing on LOST taking place in a physical world well before the finale. However, I’ve yet to find someone who syncs up 100% with what I’m doing, esp when we start getting into the Undershow — I’ll save that one for later! Unless I specifically note it, everything I post comes from my own head (disturbing, right?). All I can say is what I always say: I only follow the evidence.
Do most of the people on this site agree with your theory? Just asking.
Always feel free to ask questions! We love it! The simplest answer is: maybe. LOSTblog was developed and set up to facilitate rewatch and post-finale activities, all based on the idea that this is supposed to be FUN. What’s so very cool about rewatch, and about LOSTblog in general, is that the guess work is over. Now is the time to TEST our theories against the show as a whole. Everyone on LOSTblog is very excited and really digging in, which I LOVE! If you’ve explored other writers on the site and LOSTblog peeps’ discussions on our podcasts, then you know there’s a wide spectrum of theories about the show represented here. Right now, we are all at the “maybe” stage. For the most part what I’ve heard is — okay, so I can agree it’s not physically real (since the finale made that pretty darn clear), so where does that leave us? Now is the time to ask more questions. The best way to do that is to start from scratch and work together. That’s what makes the show so cool in the first place!
Hopefully, you’ve also noticed that at LOSTblog we work very hard to keep our discussions friendly, fun and interesting without putting anyone down or making anyone feel “wrong” or “stupid” about their ideas. LOSTblog is a hater-free zone *– ALWAYS! So feel free to ask your questions — they are NOT stupid!
Did that answer your question? All I’ll say for now is that it’s become a lot easier for other peeps on this site to “see” what I’m talking about. That is way cool in itself!
*FYI for all lovely LOST readers: Hater-free zone is exactly what it implies. Any and all opinions and constructive criticisms are welcomed here with open arms. However, comments laced with insults, condescension and hurtful intent will be completely ignored and immediately deleted, regardless of subject or target (Team LOSTblog or other lovely LOST readers). [Welcome to Rewatch, jerkies!!]
O.K. Here are a few questions. Please forgive me if they seem stupid, but I’m still trying to get my non scientific mind around this.
There are NO stupid questions when it comes to LOST! And FYI: I’m an English Lit/Freshman Comp teacher! I’m right there with you!










